Permanence

Can a redaction be undone?

Yes, if the method merely covers the text. Redact a copy, save it as a new file and test the result before it leaves your control.

Last reviewed against Information Commissioner's Office, GOV.UK and DLA Piper. Sources

A tangled green line leading to an arrow

The risk

Covered is not removed

The ICO's advice for small organisations is blunt: when you redact on a computer, save the output as a new file [12]. The reason is practical. Where a mark has only been laid over text, the text can sit underneath it. The ICO's wider guidance exists to head off accidental breaches caused by hidden personal information and by redaction errors [5].

A hooded figure holding up three masks

On paper

Check by eye

With paper records, check that nothing can be read behind the black mark, even after scanning or photocopying [12]. Test the copy you will send, not the page you marked.

On screen

A test sequence

  1. 1

    Redact a copy and leave the original untouched.
  2. 2

    Save the redacted version as a new file [12].
  3. 3

    Open the new file and try to select, search for and copy the text you removed.
  4. 4

    Look for hidden content in the file, using the ICO's checklists as a guide [5].
  5. 5

    Record that the test happened and who ran it.

Formats

Simpler is safer

For spreadsheets the ICO suggests converting to a simpler format such as CSV, which reveals everything that can be displayed [6]. The same instinct holds for other files: the fewer layers a format carries, the fewer places data can hide.

Keep the original

Leave the unredacted original where it is. If your method fails, you still have the source to start again from, and the requester has received nothing they should not.

Two servers, one on fire, with circular arrows and a laptop

Who tests

Not the person who redacted

The person who made the redactions is the worst placed to find what they missed, because they know what the page was meant to look like. Give the test to the independent checker, and give that person the steps above in writing.

A rocket rising over a bar chart

Next

Look at real failures

Two UK cases show what hidden data costs. See redaction failures.

How CyPro can help

Need a hand getting ready?

Reading the rules is one job. Mapping them to your organisation, closing the gaps and showing the evidence are several more. CyPro's consultants can take any of them off your plate.

Security lead advising a board

Fractional CISO for the board

A senior security lead who advises the board on what to fix first, what to accept and what to tell customers, and owns the decision record.

More on cypro.co.uk
Penetration tester probing an application for weaknesses

Penetration testing

A focused test of your systems and the controls around them, so you know they hold before an attacker finds out for you.

More on cypro.co.uk
Cyber security consultants planning hardening work

Hardening and segmentation

Our consultants put the controls in place that limit the damage when something is missed: firewall rules, network isolation and tighter admin access.

More on cypro.co.uk
Security analysts monitoring systems around the clock

24/7 security monitoring

Our SOC analysts watch your systems day and night for the signs of an attack in progress: unexpected processes, new outbound connections, logins that do not fit.

More on cypro.co.uk
Incident responders containing an attack

Incident response

If you may already be compromised, our responders contain it, preserve the evidence, find out what was touched and get you running again safely.

More on cypro.co.uk
Scanner checking internet-facing systems for weaknesses

Vulnerability scanning

Find every internet-facing system you run, including the forgotten ones, and see which are still on a vulnerable build.

See the scanning service
Rocket launching from a cloud

Get ready

Need to know what this means for you?

A disclosure that leaks, or a redaction you cannot explain, becomes a complaint to the ICO. A GDPR consultant can review your disclosure workflow, exemption log and release checks before a request tests them.