Case studies

Lessons from two disclosure failures

Both cases ended in an ICO reprimand. One involved a document that went to the wrong family, the other a spreadsheet with hidden data.

Last reviewed against Information Commissioner's Office, GOV.UK and DLA Piper. Sources

A round gauge with low, medium and high bands

Case one

Birmingham Children's Trust

The ICO reprimanded the Trust on 13 May 2024. A plan handed to one family contained personal details, and criminal allegations, relating to a child in a different family [9]. Text had been transferred from meeting minutes by mistake [9].

Two figures at an open control cabinet with a red alarm light

Case two

Southend-on-Sea City Council

A spreadsheet released to answer an FOI request held hidden data that exposed sensitive personal details of council staff. The ICO's enforcement page records a reprimand dated 14 October 2024 [10]. The Register reported that the council found the exposure on 27 October 2023, about five months after upload, and that it stopped using Excel spreadsheets in FOI responses [11].

A hooded figure at a laptop surrounded by warning icons

Compared

What they share

BirminghamSouthend
Record typeChild protection planSpreadsheet
What went wrongAnother family's details copied inHidden data in the file
ICO actionReprimandReprimand
ICO recommendation or reactionCheck by someone other than the authorNotice urging an end to publishing source Excel files, per The Register

Lessons

Four to take away

The common thread is that a second reader and a tested file count for more than good intentions. From these two cases:

  • Write a procedure, so judgement is not left to the moment [9].
  • Check the output, not the source.
  • Treat spreadsheets as high risk [6].
  • Keep a record, so your approach can be explained later [3].

A fair reading

Neither case was an access response. They are disclosure failures in other settings, and the ICO's guidance on disclosing documents applies to both kinds of release [5].

A rocket launching from a laptop beside a bar chart and a money bag

What the cases do not show

Limits of the evidence

Two reprimands cannot tell you how common such failures are. They show how a failure happens and what the regulator asked for in return. Use them as test cases for your own process.

A cloud, a shield with a padlock and a database linked together

Next

Put it into practice

The action plan turns these lessons into steps.

How CyPro can help

Need a hand getting ready?

Reading the rules is one job. Mapping them to your organisation, closing the gaps and showing the evidence are several more. CyPro's consultants can take any of them off your plate.

Security lead advising a board

Fractional CISO for the board

A senior security lead who advises the board on what to fix first, what to accept and what to tell customers, and owns the decision record.

More on cypro.co.uk
Penetration tester probing an application for weaknesses

Penetration testing

A focused test of your systems and the controls around them, so you know they hold before an attacker finds out for you.

More on cypro.co.uk
Cyber security consultants planning hardening work

Hardening and segmentation

Our consultants put the controls in place that limit the damage when something is missed: firewall rules, network isolation and tighter admin access.

More on cypro.co.uk
Security analysts monitoring systems around the clock

24/7 security monitoring

Our SOC analysts watch your systems day and night for the signs of an attack in progress: unexpected processes, new outbound connections, logins that do not fit.

More on cypro.co.uk
Incident responders containing an attack

Incident response

If you may already be compromised, our responders contain it, preserve the evidence, find out what was touched and get you running again safely.

More on cypro.co.uk
Scanner checking internet-facing systems for weaknesses

Vulnerability scanning

Find every internet-facing system you run, including the forgotten ones, and see which are still on a vulnerable build.

See the scanning service
Rocket launching from a cloud

Get ready

Need to know what this means for you?

A disclosure that leaks, or a redaction you cannot explain, becomes a complaint to the ICO. A GDPR consultant can review your disclosure workflow, exemption log and release checks before a request tests them.